diff --git a/pt100/pt100.tex b/pt100/pt100.tex index 48d708d..ab1da3a 100644 --- a/pt100/pt100.tex +++ b/pt100/pt100.tex @@ -111,16 +111,19 @@ $R_2$ SHORT & - & Low & Value Out of Range Value \\ From table \ref{ptfmea} it can be seen that any component failure in the circuit will cause a common symptom, that of one or more of the values being out of range. -So by defining an acceptable measurement/temperature range, and ensuring the +Temperature range calculations and detailed calculations +on the effects of each test case are found in section \ref{pt100range} +and \ref{pt100temp}. So by defining an acceptable measurement/temperature range, and ensuring the values are always within these bounds we can be confident that none of the resistors in this circuit has failed. + \subsection{Single Fault Modes as PLD} % Place in PLD diagram \subsection{Range and PT100 Calculations} - +\label{pt100temp} PT100 resistors are designed to have a resistance of ohms{100} at 0 \oc \cite{eurothermtables}. A suitable `wider than to be expected range' was considered to be {-100\oc} to {300\oc}. @@ -166,6 +169,69 @@ Table \ref{ptbounds} gives ranges that determine correct operation. In fact it c for any single error (short or opening of any resistor) this bounds check will detect it. +\subsection{Proof of Out of Range Values for Failures} +\label{pt110range} +Using the temperature ranges defined above we can compare the voltages +we would get from the resistor failures to prove that they are +`out of range'. There are six cases and each will be examined in turn. + +\subsubsection{ Voltages $R_1$ SHORT } +With pt100 at -100\oc +$$ highreading = 5V $$ +Since the highreading or sense+ is directly connected to the 5V rail, +both temperature readings will be 5V.. +$$ lowreading = 5V.\frac{2k2}{2k2+68\Omega} = 4.85V$$ +With pt100 at the high end of the temperature range 300\oc. +$$ highreading = 5V $$ +$$ lowreading = 5V.\frac{2k2}{2k2+212.02\Omega} = 4.56V$$ + +Thus with $R_1$ shorted both readingare outside the +proscribed range in table \ref{ptbounds}. + +\subsubsection{ Voltages $R_1$ OPEN } + +In this case the 5V rail is disconnected. All voltages read are 0V, and +therefore both readings are outside the +proscribed range in table \ref{ptbounds}. + +\subsubsection{ Voltages $R_p$ SHORT } + +Here the potential divider is simply between +the two 2k2 load resistors. Thus it will read a nominal; +2.5V. + +Assuming the load resistors are +precision components, and then taking an absolute worst case of 1\% either way. + +$$ 5V.\frac{2k2*0.99}{2k2*1.01+2k2*0.99} = 2.475V $$ + +$$ 5V.\frac{2k2*1.01}{2k2*1.01+2k2*0.99} = 2.525V $$ + +These readings both lie outside the proscribed range. +Also the sense+ and sense- readings would have the same value. + +\subsubsection{ Voltages $R_p$ OPEN } + +Here the potential divider is broken. The sense- will read 0V and the sense+ will +read 5V. Both readings are outside the proscribed range. + +\subsubsection{ Voltages $R_2$ SHORT } + +With pt100 at -100\oc +$$ lowreading = 0V $$ +Since the lowreading or sense- is directly connected to the 0V rail, +both temperature readings will be 0V. +$$ lowreading = 5V.\frac{68\Omega}{2k2+68\Omega} = 0.15V$$ +With pt100 at the high end of the temperature range 300\oc. +$$ highreading = 5V $$ +$$ lowreading = 5V.\frac{212.02\Omega}{2k2+212.02\Omega} = 0.44V$$ + +Thus with $R_2$ shorted both readingare outside the +proscribed range in table \ref{ptbounds}. +\subsubsection{ Voltages $R_2$ OPEN } +Here there is no potential divider operating and both sense lines +will read 5V, outside of the proscibed range. + %\vbox{ %\subsubsection{Calculating Bounds: High Value : HP48 RPL} %